Honoring Those Who Really “Made History”
Sermon for Sunday, May 24, 2009 (Year B, Easter 7, Memorial Day Weekend)
And they cast lots… and the lot fell on Matthias, and he was added to the eleven apostles. (Acts 1:26)
According to the Book of Acts, it is during the ten days between the Ascension and the Day of Pentecost that Jesus’ friends finally address the impact of Judas’ treachery. For the past forty days they have been preoccupied. As Luke notes, “After his suffering” the risen Lord “presented himself alive to them by many convincing proofs… and speaking about the kingdom of God.” (Acts 1:3) The risen Christ instructed them to remain in Jerusalem until “the promise of the Father” (Acts 1:4) came upon them and they were baptized with the Holy Spirit. Then Jesus ascended into heaven, leaving them alone to contemplate what the next few days might bring.
It seems to have been at this moment that they finally recognized how Judas’ betrayal had distorted their fellowship. For three years they had been twelve; now they were eleven. In Old Testament numerology twelve is a potent number. Twelve was the number of Jacob’s sons and thus of Israel’s tribes. Perhaps for this reason numbers divisible by twelve keep reappearing in the Old Testament — the twenty-four classes of priests and Levites, (1 Chron. 24:4; 25:31) the forty-eight Levitical cities (Num. 35:7), and the seventy-two elders, including Eldad and Medad (Num. 121:24-26). This pattern carries over into the New Testament, as when St. John the Divine in his Revelation mentions the twenty-four elders standing around the throne of God (Rev. 4:4, 5:8), and the 144,000 servants of God, with 12,000 taken from each of the twelve tribes. The number twelve suggests wholeness.
To the disciples, to be just eleven must have felt very strange, very incomplete. So they decide to replace Judas with someone else. Thus we have the election of Matthias. This ritual of replacement is rather mysterious, I think, because we know so little about both Judas and the man who took his place.
Despite being history’s most notorious villain, Judas Iscariot is very much a cipher. As one commentator notes, “The meaning of his name… his background, his character, his motive in betraying Jesus, the manner of his death — all are riddles now quite insolvable.” (E.P. Blair, Interpreter’s Dictionary of the Bible, Vol. 2, p. 1006) Judas may have been from the town of Kerioth in Judea, thus making him the only non-Galilean disciple. Some speculate that he was related to Martha, Mary, and Lazarus. He was clearly an important member of the Lord’s circle of disciples, being chosen to serve as its treasurer. Jesus and Judas were probably quite close at the beginning. Judas, like the other disciples, is sent out to preach and heal and cast out demons in Jesus’ name.
Did the two have a falling out? Was Judas’ early enthusiasm dampened by the kind of people Jesus associated with, or was he disappointed when Jesus failed to stage an insurrection against Israel’s enemies? Did he betray Jesus in order either to trigger or to prevent a showdown in Jerusalem between Jesus and the Romans? Or was Judas motivated by simple greed? The gnostic idea that Judas acted on Jesus’ orders, so that Jesus could be freed from the prison of mortal flesh, is hardly credible. In any case, it seems beyond question that Judas betrayed his Master — whether or not for thirty pieces of silver, with or without the famous kiss.
The gospels differ as to what happened to Judas after the crucifixion. Matthew says he killed himself in remorse; the Book of Acts contends that he died gruesomely in a fall; and legend tells us that he roamed the earth for many years, like Cain after the murder of Abel, an object of disgust. In the end, Judas vanishes from the historical record. And in doing so he leaves a tear in the fabric of fellowship in that upper room.
To repair the damage the Eleven hold an election. Two are nominated: Justus and Matthias. Matthias is elected. Matthias who? Here we face a blank wall. If we know little for certain about Judas, we know nothing at all about this man Matthias. Undoubtedly he was a disciple, a man of good character, faithful to the Lord’s ministry. It is almost certain that after his election he labored faithfully in the Lord’s vineyard, helping the infant Church grow quickly during those crucial first few years. But aside from this, we cannot even speculate. Matthias vanishes as quickly as he appears. So why, then, should we devote a Sunday in Eastertide to someone who is, for all practical purposes, an historical unknown?
One reason, I suppose, is to remind ourselves that history is not just the product of great men and great women doing great deeds which win either the approval or disapproval of historians and their readers. Historians focus on great people mainly because they leave a paper trail — diaries, memoirs, letters, documents by and about them. Sifting, evaluating, and presenting this residue of documentary evidence is what historians do.
Moreover, these great people are often very conscious of their place in history and expend no small effort to persuade historians to speak well of them. They may believe that their contribution was or still is crucial; that the fate of nations turned and still turns on their decisions; and that civilization will implode if their successors fail to discern the truth which these great people see so clearly. Given his recent statements, former Vice President Dick Cheney seems intent on casting in bronze the memory of his eight years in office (and garnering some publicity for his forthcoming autobiography) while disparaging those who do not share his views. But this too —and he too — shall pass. His book will sell nicely. Then Mr. Cheney will join the silent pantheon of vice presidents, and in a few years the community of historians will begin to render fair judgement on his work.
However, I think we should remember that history is not made just by great people. Great people certainly count, but they count only because many more small people — people whose names and deeds rarely appear in any history book — did their part. Those who claim to see so far and so clearly do so only because they stand on the shoulders of others.
- For instance, those who signed our Declaration of Independence and assured their neighbors that life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness were God-given rights would hardly be remembered today if their neighbors had not backed their cause.
- In 1848 Lucretia Mott and Elizabeth Cady Stanton set in motion the fight for women’s suffrage, but they would be mere footnotes in history were it not for the women in their thousands who demanded equality.
- Eleanor Roosevelt chaired the United Nations commission which in 1948 gained approval for the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. This remarkable document recognizes that “the inherent dignity and… the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world.” It declares that no member of the human family shall be enslaved, subjected to arbitrary arrest or detention, tortured, deprived of the freedom of conscience and religion, and much more. (UDHR, 1948) But great as her contribution was, Mrs. Roosevelt could have accomplished little without the support of many human rights advocates around the globe, most of whom are unknown.
- Martin Luther King Jr. and Nelson Mandela fought for their dreams of racial equality with uncommon grace and tenacity, but it is the hundreds of thousands of American and South African citizens who shared their cause who, in fact, “made history.”
I mention this because this weekend we honor the memory of many, many Americans —most of whose names are remembered only by their families, if at all — who “made history” by serving their country in time of war. Our national custom of honoring the war dead by decorating their graves most likely began in 1865 when liberated slaves in Charleston, South Carolina, decorated the mass grave of Union soldiers at the site of that city’s former Confederate prison camp. The following year a memorial observance was held in the village of Waterloo, New York, which is now credited as the birthplace of Memorial Day. In 1868 the Grand Army of the Republic issued an order calling for decoration of service members’ graves throughout the nation on May 30th. The order declares, “If other eyes grow dull and other hands slack, and other hearts cold in the solemn trust, ours shall keep it well as long as the light and warmth of life remain in us.” From its roots in the Civil War, the event grew across the years to include the war dead of all conflicts.
But Memorial Day is no celebration of war, nor is it the occasion to hymn great presidents or great generals. Rather, Memorial Day commemorates the sacrifice made by countless individual Americans across the generations. It recognizes that, at crucial moments, men and women have been called away from all that was familiar — from their homes, families, schools, jobs, and communities — to defend our country. With rare exception they have done so with courage and honor, respecting the rules of war, being resolute in battle and compassionate in victory, and often returning home with little fanfare, seeking only to pick up their lives where they left off. Like Matthias, they have been elected to serve in their generation. Their works may not be even a footnote in a history book, but they served well and faithfully, and we are in their debt.
Great people — or those who imagine themselves to be great — may try to claim the lion’s share of honor, believing their wisdom and their decisions are the hinge on which history turns. But in the end, what we have, we owe to these average men and women whose labors may be little known to us, but are surely known to God.
May the honored dead rest in peace. Amen.
— The Rev. John E. Laycock, Interim Pastor
Readings for Year B, Easter 7:
Lesson: Acts 1:15-17, 21-26
Gradual: Psalm 1
Epistle: 5:9-13
John 17:6-19
Collect for Easter 7:
O God, the King of glory, you hve exalted your only Son Jesus Christ with great triumph to your kingdom in heaven: Do not leave us comfortless, but send us your Holy Spirit to strengthen us, and exalt us to that place where our Savior Christ has gone before; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, in glory everlasting. Amen.
A Collect for All in the Service of Our Country:
O Almighty Lord God, who neither slumberest nor sleepest: Protect and assist, we beseech thee, all those who at home or abroad, by land, by sea, or in the air, are serving this country, that they, being armed with thy defense, may be preserved evermore in all perils; and being filled with wisdom and girded with strength, may do their duty to thy honor and glory; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
From A Prayer Book for Soldiers and Sailors
Published by the Episcopal Church for Use during World War Two